2023
- January -
- February The Serpent and the Wings of Night Carissa Broadbent
- March A Darker Shade of Magic VE Schwab
- April Legends and Lattes Travis Baldree
- May The Ashes and the Star-Crossed King Carissa Broadbent
- June Fouth Wing Rebecca Yarros
- July Belladonna Adalyn Grace
- August One Dark Window Rachel Gillig
- September Divine Rivals Rebecca Ross
- October The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches Sangu Mandanna
- November Iron Flame Rebecca Yarros
- December -
2024
- January Ruthless Vows Rebecca Ross
- February The Forgotten Goddess Rebecca Sinclair
- March Bride Ali Hazelwood
- April A Fate Inked in Blood Danielle Jensen
- May The Familiar Leigh Bardugo
- June The Honey Witch Sydney Shields
- July Trial of the Sun Queen Nisha Tuli
- August To Kill A Kingdom Alexandra Christo
- September Ninth House Leigh Bardugo
- October Heartless Hunter Kristen Ciccarelli
- Novemeber Two Twisted Crowns Rachel Gillig
- December Six Scorched Roses Carissa Broadbent
2025
- January For the Wolf Hannah Whitten
- February Under Loch and Key Lara Ferguson
- March The Spellshop Sarah Durst
- April Six of Crows Leigh Bardugo
- May Daughter of No Worlds Carissa Broadbent
- June The Games Gods Play Abigail Owen
- July A Tempest of Tea Hafsah Faizal
- August Avalon Tower CN Crawford and Alex Rivers
- September Don't Let the Forest In CG Drews
- October Phantasma Kaylie Smith
- November Enchantra Kaylie Smith
- December The Brothers Grimm
2026
- January Red Rising Pierce Brown
- February Tempests and Tea Leaves Rachel Morgan
- March The Wren in the Holly Library KA Linde
- April Five Broken Blades Mai Corland
- May The Knight and the Moth Rachel Gillig
- June The Ever King LJ Andrews
- July Practical Magic Alice Hoffman
- August A Fate Forged in Fire Hazel McBride
- September
- October
- November
- December